The electoral college should be abolished i believe the electoral college was established at a time when much fewer people voted, fewer people had basic educations, and voting only took place in states, leaving the possibility of a single large state virginia dominating the election very possible. Several years after the united states was founded, the constitutional convention met to decide how the new nation would govern itself. S election history such as the election of 2000 that should show that the system at the very least needs an overhaul and should be removed from existence. The electoral college should be abolished 1155 words 5 pages. The electoral college should be abolished 886 words 123. Sophisticated use of a substantial number of documents. Lastly, circle the numbers of the specific arguments that you find the most convincing on the side that you agree with. Some people believe that the electoral college is undemocratic and should be abolished.
Constitution at the documents founding in 1789, should be abolished. The electoral college is the electoral college outdated or still relevant. The electoral college is a critical part of the concept of federalism, and. The electoral college was a compromise between election of the president by a vote in congress and election of the president by a popular vote of qualified citizens. Adam ruins everything why the electoral college ruins. Dec 18, 2009 read this social issues essay and over 89,000 other research documents. This is not to say that the electoral college is perfect. It is flawed and should be abolished for a number of reasons. Why should the electoral college be abolished 9 words 4 pages. The idea of the electoral college was first introduced in this constitution as a way to make sure that there was a buffer between the population and the selection of a president. Free electoral college essays and papers 123helpme.
The representatives of small states do not vote as a bloc in congress. Read the title together and clarify the meaning of the word. The dbq title should the electoral college be abolished is intended to teaching students to become better analytical thinkers. One reason why the electoral college should be abolished is because the. They each focus on different problems caused by the electoral college. Primary source lesson plan should the electoral college be. For these reasons is why the electoral college should. This chart shows the majority of the united states can agree that the electoral college should be abolished. Most americans think the electoral college is a nuanced and complex system designed to safeguard democracy. Instances of the electoral college failing the electoral college is the institution that officially elects the president and vicepresident of the united states. The electoral college should should not be abolished. The electoral college has always had strong opponents who have argued that it should be abolished.
There is no coherent small state interest that needs protecting by the electoral college. Nor is this concern entirely unfounded since there. Anderson analyzes the arguments for and against the electoral college. Nov 16, 2016 that year, akhil reed amar wrote in an oped for the new york times that the electoral college should be abolished, and charles fried disagreed. Why not abolish the electoral college, make every citizens vote. Feb 06, 2017 clearly it shouldnt be there if only the people should count. Every 4 years, our country makes an incredibly important decision. Government had been based on the articles of confederation, which had virtually no execu tive branchthat is, no single leader, such as the. Get an answer for should the electoral college be abolished. Reason for abolishing the electoral college politics essay.
April 2nd pols 1100 persuasive essay electoral college. Clark us government 2 december 2018 should the electoral college be abolished. Tim alberta is national political reporter at politico magazine. The republicans tend to lean more to keeping the system, but for the most part it is unflavored. Since the electoral college system has been added to our constitution hundreds of years ago, many things have changed in our country. An important aspect of our country is the fact that we are a democracy and we feel we should ultimately have a say in government. The electoral college is not going to be changed, and there are far more urgent and promising topics for reform of our presidential selection system it is true that the electoral college no longer serves its. The electoral college thus presents democratic risks without serving any of its original purposes. The explanation must be tied to the national perspective.
How could you use this document to argue that the electoral college should be abolished. The official general election results indicate that trump received 304 electoral college. The twoparty system solves the fractured vote problem more effectively than the electoral college ever did, and the electors never exercised genuine independence. Choose the strongest argument for keeping or abolishing the electoral.
We vote for the person who will represent the us in all domestic and international affairs. Why the electoral college should be abolished essay. While many want to abolish the system of the electoral college, there is not a functional option to replace it yet. Nov 21, 2016 the electoral college is outdated and needs to be abolished. Students will analyze role of the electoral college in u. How could this document help support abolishing or keeping the electoral college. How would you react if you learned that the presidential candidate you had cast your vote for, had actually received. In argument one, the author cites several different historic examples, but in argument two, she only references the 1960 election to prove her point. The electoral college should be abolished essay 877 words. The electoral college is outdated and needs to be abolished. Students will debate whether the electoral college system should be. After analyzing the sources given, i believe the electoral college should be abolished, if not changed at the.
Abolishing the system at a time in the us like this, where we have many ongoing problems and issues the economy, international relations, ect would not be smart. That is not to say the electoral college is without its advantages. Students will then prepare for an essay, a debate, or a presentation in which they will present evidence from the documents to back up their arguments. The target will be thoughtful answers from students. Jan 12, 2017 the electoral college was created, in part, to make the states feel important in a federalist government. A second way in which the electoral college fails to accurately reflect the national popular. Currently, we have many troops in iraq fighting to help them establish a democracy. This dbq will ask you answer whether or not the electoral college is a good system for electing the president and vicepresident in the 21st century. Democracy is based on majority rule, and that election showed the major flaw of the electoral college. Its time to abolish the electoral college brookings institution.
The electoral college doesnt treat all americans equally. There are several reasons the electoral college may be called unfair, but three of those reasons stand out over the rest. In addition, there was considerable discussion regarding whether congress or state legislatures should choose the chief executive. Adam ruins everything why the electoral college ruins democracy. Were not an offshore paper mill grinding out questionable should electoral college be abolished essay research and inferior writing. Why the electoral college should be abolished essay bartleby. But action must involve the laborious efforts required to amend the.
That year, akhil reed amar wrote in an oped for the new york times that the electoral college should be abolished, and charles fried disagreed. When dealing with issues concerning the electoral college, many people get confused. One point is earned for each correct explanation of why the electoral college has not been abolished. For these reasons, the constitution should be changed, and the electoral college should be abolished. Electoral college miniq ev should the electoral college be abolished. I should start off saying that, the electoral college is a process, not a place as many think. The electoral college is far from perfect, there have been many fairly recent events in u. If you would like a structure of the essay for all 5 paragraphs check out the essay outline for the electoral college dbq or the essay outline for the voting dbq. The debate over the continued use of the electoral college resurfaced during the 2016 presidential election, when donald trump lost the general election to hillary clinton by over 2. After looking at the documents, students should craft a thesis statement. He contends that the system was originally created as a means to enhance. Amendment, which is the closest the united states congress has ever come to abolishing the. Start studying should the electoral college be abolished learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
The electoral college is supposed to guarantee that populous states cant dominate an election, but it also sets up a disparity in representation. Why we should abolish the electoral college huffpost. Should electoral college be abolished essay all academic levels. Download as docx, pdf, txt or read online from scribd.
The electoral college should continue to be the system of voting. Primary source lesson plan should the electoral college. How did the electoral college help their concern over uniformed voters. Then decide if you think that the electoral college should remain or be abolished. For these reasons is why the electoral college should be kept without it we. Each floridians potential vote, then, carried about one third the weight of a potential vote in the other states listed. The electoral college is under fresh assault on the heels of donald trumps victory last novemberthe second time in five. The electoral college should be abolished the presidential election process, 2008 why has this anachronistic system. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment ratified june 15, 1804, the fourteenth amendment ratified july 1868, and the twentythird amendment ratified mar. The electoral college is neither a disaster or outdated, and it is as vital to our republic today as it was in 1787. May 16, 2010 the electoral college should be abolished. What should be done with the electoral collegekeep it, reform it, or replace it with something different. The president and vicepresident are not directly elected by the voters. The electoral college was established in 1787 because the framers at the constitutional convention weren t convinced that the people of the united states were intelligent enough to vote for their own leader.
660 1090 1187 449 34 668 10 1602 1459 55 17 1595 1399 1337 1641 1339 989 571 1068 1535 808 239 453 1029 1340 728 785 1359 888 1048 135 1470 920 1329 1442